SUMMARY: ColoRectal Cancer (CRC) is the third most common cancer diagnosed in both men and women in the United States. The American Cancer Society estimates that approximately 135,430 new cases of ColoRectal Cancer will be diagnosed in the United States in 2017 and over 50,260 patients are expected to die of the disease. Several published studies have demonstrated a nearly 20% reduced risk of death for patients diagnosed with left sided colon cancer compared with those who had right sided tumors. Venook and colleagues had previously presented their findings from a retrospective evaluation of the phase III 80405 clinical trial which included data from 1,025 metastatic ColoRectal Cancer patients with KRAS wild-type disease. The researchers assessed the impact of tumor location on Overall and Progression Free Survival in this group of patients. The median age was 59 yrs and 293 patients had a right-sided primary tumor (location in the cecum to hepatic flexure) and 732 patients had a left-sided primary tumor (location in the splenic flexure to rectum). It was noted that patients with tumors originating in the right side of the colon had much shorter median Overall Survival (19.4 months) compared to patients with left-sided tumors (33.3 months), (HR=1.60; P<0.001), with a 14 month survival improvement in the left versus right-sided primary tumors, for patients with metastatic disease. Tumor location in the colon also had a bearing on response to ERBITUX® (Cetuximab) and AVASTIN® (Bevacizumab). For the patient group who received ERBITUX®, the median Overall Survival (OS) was 36 months for patients with left-sided tumors but only 16.7 months for patients with right-sided tumors. For those who received AVASTIN®, the median OS was 31.4 months for patients with left-sided tumors and 24.2 months for those with right-sided tumors. The median Progression Free Survival was also influenced by the site of the primary tumor and was 11.5 months for left-sided tumors versus 8.9 months for right-sided tumors in the overall cohort of patients (HR = 1.26; P = 0.002). It was concluded that the biology of tumors originating in the right colon may be different from those originating in the left colon and regardless of KRAS mutational status, AVASTIN® based, first line chemotherapy regimen should be considered, for all patients with metastatic colorectal cancer, with a right-sided colon primary tumor and ERBITUX® should be avoided in this patient group.
Understanding that there is a difference in outcomes with biologic therapy, based on tumor location in the colon, the authors in this study evaluated the molecular variations of tumors arising in different parts of the left colon. Using protein expression, gene amplification and NextGen sequencing, 1,457 primary tumors (125 from splenic flexure to descending colon, 460 in the sigmoid colon and 872 in the rectum) were examined. MicroSatellite Instability (MSI) was measured by PCR and tumor mutational load was calculated using somatic nonsynonymous missense mutations.
They noted that the incidence of to MSI significantly decreased from right colon (22%), to descending colon (7%),sigmoid colon (4%) to rectum (1%) and this was statistically significant (P=0.01). Rectal tumors had a higher frequency of TP53 and APC gene mutations and higher expression of TOPO1, ERCC1 and MGMT, compared to tumors in the descending colon. Compared to sigmoid colon tumors, rectal tumors had a higher expression of TOPO1, MGMT, TLE3 and TUBB3.
The authors concluded that tumors arising in the rectum have a distinct set of genetic alterations compared with other left colon tumors, and these distinct biologic entities may need to be addressed with individually tailored therapy. Molecular variances between rectal and left-sided colon cancers. Marshall J, Lenz H, Xiu J, et al. J Clin Oncol 35, 2017 (suppl 4S; abstract 522)
